The second occurrence of "Is This a Game?" ("これはゲームなのか?") took place Dec. 7-15, 2019 in Tokyo. I wrote about the first such event in a Dec. 2018 post that featured the final published version of Stonehenge and the Sun, a design from Naotaka Shimamoto and itten that was shown during that event in an earlier form.
At this new event, 17 "experimental" game designers displayed more than twice as many works as at the first show in a space that was four times as large in order to allow visitors to have more access. Here's one user's post about the experience:
@isthis_a_game was such a cool experience! How far these designers push the limits of game design is astonishing!
— Engro Games (@JapanBoardGamer) December 7, 2019
Plus I got to "eat" a master chef's day-old artichoke olive porridge and raw custard ice cream with @TheJordanDraper, @44gi, and Nozomi from @itten_games_en!
😂 pic.twitter.com/TKcY07azsm
It's a mega game played by exhibition attendees. They place rectangular blocks on a grid and choose a black or red standing, sitting, or walking figure. At the end of the exhibition, score will be tallied based off a number of different scoring conditions to see which side won.
— Engro Games (@JapanBoardGamer) December 7, 2019
By clicking on the upper-left image, you can see progress in that block game in this tweet from someone four days after the one above:
#なのか展 の会場をお掃除してきました!!
— とりまる丸 (@tori_marumaru) December 11, 2019
新しい!?新鮮?!楽しいヾ(*'ω'*)ノ゙
けど、どこか懐かしくてそのことを語りたい人を思い出したりして...( ᵕᴗᵕ ) pic.twitter.com/XQZJWsE0k4
Japanese game publisher ASOBI.dept plans to sell pins featuring the event's logo, and it's a nicely evocative pin whether you know anything about the event or not — which seems in the spirit of the event since these creations often seem like the rules are as much what you make of them as what the designer has given to you.
#なのか展 のグッズの仕上げをしています。前回に引き続き木製バッジと、新しく作ったアクリルピンズです!普通に自分でも欲しくなるくらい良い仕上がりです✨
— ASOBI.dept / アソビデプト (@asobi_dept) December 6, 2019
公式グッズも色々とご用意していますのでお楽しみに!https://t.co/9GzwAtmm7n pic.twitter.com/xNgCHfbLYk
At the 2018 event, one of the designs featured was titled "一年生" ("One Year Game") from Nilgiri of doujin publisher するめデイズ (Surume Days), with Nilgiri being one of the organizers of this event. "One Year Game" featured a playing time of (as you might expect) one year ("一年"). Saigo — a JP-to-EN translator who often tweets about JP games in English — explains the game in some detail in this Twitter thread, but the general idea is that you would take one of the boxes, write actions on the three rule cards, close the box again, then take home another box that someone else had completed and over the next year, you would record on the rule cards when you took the actions listed on them. One year later, you would meet others who were playing the game, receive the box that you initially wrote rules for, then score points based on how many times that other player took the actions you had specified.
Nilgiri posted an overview of the one year party that took place in May 2019, which had nearly fifty people show up to talk about what they had done in the previous twelve months: "It was a mysterious experience to feel familiarity here even though it was the first meeting for us. Looking back now, I can't think of a similar experience."
The designer talks about how the rules presented to them influenced their actions, with a last-minute trip to a concert by Ringo Shiina to score 100 points for whoever had submitted that rule in their box: "But these are not my scores. The person who thought about the rule, only that person is in trouble if the action is not done. Still, I couldn't help it. There was a mysterious feeling like living with a stranger, an almost transparent person for a year."
Japanese publisher itten has tweeted pics and short summaries in English of several exhibits form the 2019 show, so let's look at those:
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 7, 2019
Jordan Draper’s “I’d eat it.”
Creators come up with a course meal using 9 ingredient. If you like the course, you say “I’d eat it!”@isthis_a_game @TheJordanDraper pic.twitter.com/LsWmMwScFt
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 7, 2019
Caramel Column’s “Fictional Masterpieces”
Based on the imaginary record jackets displayed on the wall, participants come up with the most suitable name for the fictional music pieces. @isthis_a_game @Caramel_Column pic.twitter.com/DFd5nhQYa6
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 8, 2019
FoUNtain’s “Dweller of the Game.”
Participants take the curse tag which make them wear thick glasses, walk like a crab, or start speaking to themselves. You need a coin of courage and a magical word to break the curse. @fountain_games @isthis_a_game #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/0ZzIpAXV00
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 8, 2019
FoUNtain’s “Message of the Rule”
There is a mysterious game box on the table. Players guess what the rules might be based on the notes left by the previous players.@isthis_a_game @fountain_games #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/osGk0rsCuF
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 9, 2019
itten’s “Fe”
A gigantic real life size “Fe” awaits you in the exhibition hall. Players place miniature “Fes” in the corners of the diorama city under a certain rule. @isthis_a_game @itten_games #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/NpLxaWWrnP
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 9, 2019
“Remote Viewing” by Asobi Dept. Two agents collaborate to specify the criminal’s hiding place based on the verbal info given using the remote viewing system. @isthis_a_game @asobi_dept #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/77zu4v4swn
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 10, 2019
“Creative Game, Game-like Creativity” by Satoshi Takahata (Korokoro Dou). Players take 1 block + 1 human to place on the board. Points are calculated based on how the humans have been placed at the end of the exhibition. @isthis_a_game @korokoro_dou #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/oZYmLt0900
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 10, 2019
“Garbage Throwing Game” by Nozakuni. Players draw a thing, write a farewell message on a sheet of paper, and then throw it into one of the dust bins. Players rate their experience depending on how novel and fun it was for them. @isthis_a_game @nozakuni #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/JrIJMzKzJN
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 11, 2019
“Corpse” by Jun Sasaki (Oink Games) The 3 art pieces are made out of components used in actual Oink games. It poses a question of what a “game” is by depriving game components of the game rules. Are they still “games”?@isthis_a_game @oinkgms #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/EKZZIHqM0A
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 12, 2019
“Gocco” by Xaquinel. In one of their pieces, the winning condition is when you have carefully fixed the clothespins on the two sides of the rope so the cloth won’t fall. Reimagining the most mundane things in life as “games.” @isthis_a_game @Xaquinel #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/Gl4t9BBZh4
Is This a Game #2 “Eggs of Rules” by Chocolate. You can “buy” a capsule containing a rule sheet by inserting a 100 yen coin. You may either throw it away, or keep it for a future game development. @isthis_a_game @inc_CHOCOLATE #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/U4iJdvhnSp
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 12, 2019
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 13, 2019
“Chumbacram” by IKE (Hitojarashi)
Using a fluorescent bar and 2 Chumba-cups, players perform various skills from “Roll (1pt)” to “Cross-Chumba (4pts)” but what these skills signify is totally up to the player’s imagination. @isthis_a_game @hitojarashi #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/YXotyFx2f6
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 13, 2019
“Ritual of Memory Exchange” by Kazunari Yonemitsu. Your memory will become somebody else’s memory. Somebody else’s memory will become yours. Whose memory is it now? @isthis_a_game @yonemitsu #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/nNf4kTjDKy
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 14, 2019
“Space Domino 2019” by Ryuta Yamada. Participants place colorful domino pieces on the ring-shaped plates floating in the exhibition hall. Compete for the beauty of your air-domino art pieces. @isthis_a_game @ryuta0706 #なのか展 https://t.co/GXC8RyNQlN pic.twitter.com/WE8T2NP5Uy
Is This a Game #2 “’__ ‘s Chair” by Osamu Hakamada. Seat yourself on one of the ladder chairs placed in the corners of the exhibition hall. You will find that the entire exhibition space turns into a playing board. Rules differ chair by chair. @isthis_a_game @hakamadan #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/KznvEBHTE0
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 14, 2019
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 15, 2019
“Games and Affordance, and Beyond” by Daitai. When faced with objects that we’ve played before as games, we naturally associate them with “fun” and play them without anybody explaining the rules.@isthis_a_game @DaiTai_Tokyo #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/5yC5gBQYGO
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 15, 2019
“Ghost” by Jun Sasaki (Oink Games). The transparent traffic cones can be taken & placed anywhere in the exhibition hall. Without being told so, humans sense a non-verbal “you shall not approach” rule wherever it’s been placed. @isthis_a_game @oinkgms #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/Bw7L10UoIz
Is This a Game #2
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 16, 2019
“Post Life Game” by Nilgiri. The game begins when an owner of the game’s copy passes away. 21 players designated by the deceased start playing under rules set uniquely for each player over a course of a year. @isthis_a_game @surume_days #なのか展 pic.twitter.com/jQuUFM4V4h
We’ve successfully finished the second of our Is This a Game exhibition. Thanks to all who’ve visited and experienced this new gaming experiment with us!! https://t.co/lOzhTNCPC6
— itten-games-en (@itten_games_en) December 17, 2019
Patrick Engro has expanded descriptions of some of these exhibits in an article on GameHungry.com.
Along these same lines, here's a few pics of 巨獣大進撃 ("Giant Beast Attack"), a design released at Tokyo Game Market in November 2019 by Joyple Games. Google Translate doesn't make everything clear about the gameplay, but the gist is that you use an actual atlas as the game board, with one or more players moving a monster across the surface of the world and everyone dividing up the area as the game progresses.
【巨獣大進撃】Joyple GamesさんのGM19秋新作。実際の地図帳に書き込むアブストラクト。巨獣となって地球上の線という線の上を我が物顔で練り歩く。だが誰かが歩いた線の上は通れないスペランカー巨獣だ(交差は可能)
— スゲちゃん (@sugech) December 5, 2019
相手をハメて、この星の一頭獣になりたいの怪獣で俺は!そんだけ!
❌は巨獣撃破跡 pic.twitter.com/Q8daSvsG02
I want to see more creations along these lines, and since my efforts to learn Japanese have not gotten past the numbers, I need to make this event happen in English. Therefore, with permission from Nilgiri, I've already reserved space at BGG.CON 2020 to hold an "Is This a Game?" event in the U.S. Details to come, but if you have any interest in participating, this post will ideally prompt you toward a gamey new year's resolution...