Game Overview: Hot Tin Roof, or While The Cat's Away, The Other Cat Is Lonely and Desperate

Game Overview: Hot Tin Roof, or While The Cat's Away, The Other Cat Is Lonely and Desperate
Board Game: Hot Tin Roof
In October 2015, I posted about a Seth Jaffee article about designing responsibly, that is, about designing a game so that poor choices on the part of a player won't ruin that player's enjoyment of a game (and presumably the enjoyment of all other players, too).

I disagreed with the idea of this being a goal that game designers should shoot for and mentioned Leo Colovini's Hot Tin Roof from Mayfair Games as one such example of a game that allows you to nail your foot in the ground so that you move only in circles. Said past Eric: "I still need to record a video about Hot Tin Roof, so perhaps I can dig into the topic more at that time." Well, that guy has finally done the job he promised months ago, but he forgot to mention in that video several odd details about the game:

• He forgot to cover the way that the cat colors (black, white, gray, orange) don't match the token colors (brown, purple, blue, orange), leading to some confusing moments during the game when you're not sure who owns which catwalks and shelters.

• He forgot to point out that the nicely detailed game board highlights the precise spot on the ground where the pipe over which the cats will walk is missing, thereby obscuring the important detail that the pipe is missing and this gap needs to be closed by the placement of a catwalk.

• He forgot to finger the oddness of using a can of sardines as one unit of food/currency and a fish for ten units of food/currency, despite the can of sardines having fish inside of it, which suggests that the can should be more valuable.

• He failed to note that the name "Hot Tin Roof" probably doesn't resonate with anyone under a certain age, making it a curious choice for this design, but in retrospect he acknowledges that choice as superior to "Hot Bakestone".

He's still learning how to do this. Give him another year, and he might finally remember to say all the stuff that he intended to say.

Related

New Game Round-up: Wallace Polishes Brass, Schlegel Heads West of Africa, and McKinley Ross Gets Blockier

New Game Round-up: Wallace Polishes Brass, Schlegel Heads West of Africa, and McKinley Ross Gets Blockier

Jan 04, 2016

• In December 2015, Eagle-Gryphon Games cut ties with Martin Wallace's Brass. In early January 2016, Gavan Brown of Roxley Games announced that Wallace had signed with Roxley for a new version...

Game Overview: All Queens Chess, or I Can't Believe It's Not Chess

Game Overview: All Queens Chess, or I Can't Believe It's Not Chess

Jan 03, 2016

I don't know about you, but I tend to groan when I see "chess" in the name of a new game release. From past talks with chess fans, I know that they rarely want to play anything other than chess...

Game Overview: 10 Down, or Getting Racked Over Tea

Game Overview: 10 Down, or Getting Racked Over Tea

Jan 02, 2016

Designer Odd Hackwelder seems to have a pattern for how he names games: 8 the Liar, M80, and Monster Deck 55. Okay, not all of his games fit this pattern — e.g., Ninja Bowling and counterfeit...

Game Overview: The Game on Fire, or Playing Cards Faster

Game Overview: The Game on Fire, or Playing Cards Faster

Jan 01, 2016

When I first heard about Steffen Benndorf's The Game (a.k.a. The Game: Spiel...so lange du kannst!, a.k.a. the game that's easier to find when you search for its subtitle rather than its main...

Spiel 2015 XXVI: Rising 5, Estoril 1942, I Love Portugal, Ice Cream, Ten Cats, and Generalship

Spiel 2015 XXVI: Rising 5, Estoril 1942, I Love Portugal, Ice Cream, Ten Cats, and Generalship

Dec 29, 2015

• Time for another round-up of game preview videos recorded at Spiel 2015, starting with Rising 5, a Mastermind-style game from Gary Kim and Evan Song that layers special powers onto the co-op...

ads