Designers' Preview: Starship Merchants

Designers' Preview: Starship Merchants
Board Game: Starship Merchants
By Joe Huber and Tom Lehmann

Starship Merchants is a game for 2-4 players who buy starships, customize them with equipment and pilots with special abilities, and explore and mine asteroids, competing to earn the most money by delivering materials, such as Deuterium or Ice-9, to the known galaxy.

The board is divided into four quadrants, corresponding to each of these activities during a "business cycle". The first quadrant is the Shipyard, where players can buy or lease ships. The second quadrant is the Market, where players can hire pilots, purchase equipment to improve their ships, buy refineries to increase the income from their mines, and lay claim to mines to ensure that others don't make off with them. The third quadrant is the Belt, where players operate their ships, and the fourth is the Dock, where players unload their goods and collect money.

Board Game: Starship Merchants

While ores are picked up and delivered, there is no map; movement is abstracted. Each ship has a set movement allowance, which can be used to: explore for new mines (drawn from a bag); pick up ores from mines in "local space"; steal unclaimed mines from other players' "local space"; and, if desired, travel to distant destinations for extra profit.

A player turn consists of either taking an action in the current quadrant or advancing to the next quadrant and possibly taking an action there. For example, buying or leasing a starship in the Shipyard is an action, as is running a starship in the Belt, so a player who chooses to buy and operate three ships must invest many more actions in buying and operating his fleet than a player who chooses to run a single starship. Similarly, players must weigh purchasing additional equipment or recruiting Pilots versus spending extra time in the Market. This introduces a "time versus volume of goods" trade-off that players must manage, as they move around the board in "business cycles" of varying length.

Board Game: Starship Merchants

Other decisions include whether to:

-----• Purchase Scouts, with higher movement allowances for more exploration and to reach distant destinations, or Tugs, for greater cargo capacity, when buying ships;
-----• Invest in Refineries, which improve payouts for one type of goods across one's fleet; or
-----• Invest in Claims, which both protect one's mines and improve their payouts.

Finally, starships come in four "generations", Marks I-IV, where the first Mark III ship bought obsoletes the Mark I starships and the first Mark IV starship obsoletes the Mark II ships. A player who is behind can often catch up by "shaking the box", forcing the leading players' ships into obsolescence.

Board Game: Starship Merchants
Mark I ships? Make way for Mark III!

Board Game: Starship Merchants

If a player has earned enough when entering the Dock, she may declare Game End – and with more money, must do so – earning a bonus. Once all players have made it around to the Dock, the player with the most money wins. Whether the game ends before Mark IV ships appear is a collective decision by the players, through both their ship purchases and Game End declarations.

Starship Merchants is a joint design by Joe Huber and Tom Lehmann, inspired, in part, by an earlier game, 2038, by Jim Hlavaty and Tom Lehmann.

Joe: Starship Merchants came out of a conversation at a gaming convention during a game of 2038, when the subject of an 18xx card game came up. I thought it was an interesting idea, but difficult to pull off, since card games are inherently random, while most 18xx designs have no random element. Then, an idea struck me – 2038 had already solved the problem of adding randomness to the 18xx system and could readily be adapted into an interesting card game.

The next stop on my trip was near Tom Lehmann, one of 2038's co-designers. At the time, I was getting together semi-regularly on my travels with Matt Leacock (of Pandemic fame) and Tom to playtest each others' latest games. I met with Tom beforehand for dinner and broached the idea of a "2038 card game". As we talked about it, we refined the idea – tremendously. We finished the meal with something promising, but it was neither an 18xx card game nor a 2038 card game.

Tom: I was initially taken aback by Joe's proposal – even though I had done several co-designs and played in other designers' "sandboxes" (notably Bernd Brunnhofer's Saint Petersburg, with my New Society expansion, and Matt's Pandemic – with him – for On the Brink), I wasn't used to designers asking to revisit my games. (Now that Wei-Hwa Huang has done the same with the upcoming Roll for the Galaxy, I'm getting used to it...) As I listened to Joe, however, I got excited. I could see ways to take two ideas from 2038 – exploration and mines – and really expand on them with lots of new equipment, pilots, and destinations, while at the same time freeing the game from its 18xx roots, removing the corporations, capitalization, and stock investing elements to turn it into a much brisker game.

Board Game: Starship Merchants
Two mine tiles, with the front side on the left, back side on the right

Joe: Tom and I were getting together for more playtesting Friday, and Tom arrived having scavenged parts to mock up a prototype of Starship Merchants. A few minutes later we were playing. Many of the numbers – mine values, ship costs – were off, loans didn't exist yet, and most pilots and destinations would change, but the game we played largely resembled the published game, with one major exception: While the four stages of the business cycle existed, a turn consisted of a player doing all desired actions at the current stage.

For about a year after this initial playtest, Tom and I made numerous changes and improvements, and the game was quite playable – but it was missing something: Play felt just a bit too "lockstep" and not "dynamic" enough. Gordon Hua then suggested the crucial missing piece – that players be limited to a single action per stage of the business cycle, and, thus, as they chose to take extra actions at different stages, players would proceed through the business cycle at different speeds. With this idea in hand, Tom and I reworked the game into its present form.

Board Game: Starship Merchants
Two pilots, waiting for their rides

Tom: We then spent several years pitching the game to various publishers. Finding one was a bit of a challenge as Starship Merchants is slightly "heavier" than your typical "mid-range" game. Luckily, Toy Vault saw its potential and agreed to publish it. Toy Vault improved on our presentation and increased the material considerably, adding individual ship mats to help players organize their cards and visualize play better.

The result is a fast-playing "pickup-and-deliver" game, with several different strategic paths and lots of variety and interesting decisions, where the tedium of actually travelling routes has been abstracted away. We hope that players have as much fun playing StarShip Merchants as we had developing it. Enjoy!

Board Game: Starship Merchants
Individual player mat

Related

The Art of Maciej Rebisz – A Designer's Appreciation

The Art of Maciej Rebisz – A Designer's Appreciation

Jul 11, 2012

Flashback to the spring of 2011 – Stronghold Games was looking for artists for my new science fiction deck-building game, Core Worlds. Discussions ensued about where to find these artists, and...

Brief Interviews with the 2012 Spiel/Kennerspiel des Jahres Winners

Brief Interviews with the 2012 Spiel/Kennerspiel des Jahres Winners

Jul 11, 2012

BGG's Chad Krizan (aka chaddyboy_2000) was in Berlin, Germany on Monday, July 9 when the 2012 Spiel des Jahres – Donald X. Vaccarino's Kingdom Builder from Queen Games – and the Kennerspiel...

Designer Diary: Go Designer, Go!, or How to Retheme Your Way to Publication

Designer Diary: Go Designer, Go!, or How to Retheme Your Way to Publication

Jul 10, 2012

It all started back in high school with my final project for English class, which in fact I never turned in. The first game I ever designed was "The Great Green Gorf", a silly maze-building game...

Crowdfunding Round-up: Backstabbing, Sheepherding & A Double Dose of Firefighting

Crowdfunding Round-up: Backstabbing, Sheepherding & A Double Dose of Firefighting

Jul 09, 2012

 • Gryphon Games has launched a Kickstarter project for a reprint of Sid Sackson's I'm the Boss!, this being one of the games that Gryphon acquired the license to when it bought Face2Face...

Kingdom Builder Wins the 2012 Spiel des Jahres; Village Takes Kennerspiel des Jahres

Kingdom Builder Wins the 2012 Spiel des Jahres; Village Takes Kennerspiel des Jahres

Jul 09, 2012

Donald X. Vaccarino's Kingdom Builder from Queen Games has won the 2012 Spiel des Jahres award, Germany's "game of the year" award, while the Kennerspiel des Jahres has gone to Inka and Markus...

ads