Designer Diary: The Unsung Heroes of Healthy Heart Hospital

Designer Diary: The Unsung Heroes of Healthy Heart Hospital
Board Game: Healthy Heart Hospital
The year was 2007, and Pandemic had hit the streets like a bull in a china shop. As a game designer does when they enjoy a game, they try to make their own of a similar genre as if it is a challenge.

I remember sitting on the computer in my bedroom when something sparked my mind. I quickly drew a few pictures, then grabbed a few cubes and a black bag. I tested the idea a few times. It worked. It was unique enough of an idea that I felt it was worth pursuing.

My first implementation of this design was that of an Aliens movie game: creeping aliens growing bigger the longer you left them alone, holes where the players would fight them back like a castle siege game on the popular cell phone apps of the time.

Next was a hospital administration. Doctors would be in charge of patients, running through the ropes of an ambulance ride and the ER to end up in operating rooms. This idea, though close to Pandemic, stuck as the best version. Local playtests proved this as well.

Doctors were designed to help in their own special way. Training was added. Everything was going well, including getting a bunch of thumbs-up when the game was tested at meetings of the Board Game Designers Guild of Utah (though a couple wanted a M*A*S*H theme — sorry, Steve). I decided on Healthy Heart Hospital for a name around this time, keeping the same alliteration of all my games to this point. ("Tribute and Taxes" would break this mold as it became Ibyron: Island of Discovery a year or so later, but I digress...)

The next step was to find a publisher. After a few attempts, on a whim I wrote Victory Point Games, mostly known for war games at that point. Of all the attempts, this one I thought would fail before some of the others, but quite surprisingly I received an email saying I had found the "magic door" on how to submit a game to their company and that "...we have an ever growing line of eurogames."

This was the first and not last time I would hear back from Nathan Hansen. Of course, my first email to send the rulebook and parts sheet failed. Luckily, Nathan persevered with me, and shortly thereafter I was able to send an attachment that did make it. Then, like all designers, I was very patient and didn't bug him for a whole week...

From gallery of ropearoni4
Slowly, the game started to show up on Nathan's radar of one hundred or so submissions. This was about six months from the first email, quite fast for any publisher in my experience. After the radar came the "burners". There aren't a lot of developers to work on every single design that VPG has under consideration, so we all had to wait in the back of the queue until HHH boiled to the top. Around November of that year (HHH had been on burners for eight months at this point), I heard that a developer would be assigned to HHH. Yay! And then for some reason, all my mails went into the SPAM folder for about three months. Speed bump. Boo.

That leads us to Josh Neiman, whom Nathan sent HHH to in order to be developed more fully. Up to this time, little things were fiddled with, such as adding abilities to doctors, but no deep development was going on. Josh was going to pick up the reins and develop it further...but within a month forwarded the design to their new developer: Stephen Zorn.

Zorn, as he liked to be called, was working on HHH as well as a few other designs, so HHH took a back seat a little bit so they could push another game out of the queue and to the public. I understood the problem with too many games and not enough developers — very common in my experience. He worked heavily on the rulebook and the bits and pieces, and for a short while things started humming along until they put him on a project that was to be published within a month. Backseat again.


From gallery of ropearoni4

First prototype designed by my wife Anna-Marie featuring old television sets;
who would've thought it would be an omen to the final design taking place in the 1960s


Now, this was a year from the last time Nathan worked on HHH, and due to Zorn's commitments, he had to drop HHH, and who do you think they put back on it? Nathan is back, stronger than ever...and I was sent a contract to sign. Yay!

Nathan, at the helm again. This time, he was the developer, completely. Through the next six months we got HHH ready for out-of-house testing and all was looking good. We had more ideas that were in the emails back and forth and getting those nailed down took some time.

From gallery of ropearoni4
Speed bumps do happen, remember? Though we thought we had gotten HHH all tested and ready for publication, I found out it was not ready, but this time I didn't know it immediately. My emails from Josh Neiman and Alan Emrich hit the spam bucket for some reason. For two months while I thought HHH was getting published, it was in limbo — or so I thought. Alan Emrich had placed his Euro designer hat on and had taken HHH under his wings. After perusing the many emails and talking to Petra Schlunk in the hospital field, he and she took the basics of HHH and when to town on it.

They added many ideas that made sense thematically to the game, taking a simple lightweight game and giving it tons of depth. They tested it some during this time with no input from me. Remember, I was in spam-limbo, not getting any emails of Alan's morphing of HHH. Speed bump.

For some reason, I was checking my spam folder in August and spied an email from VPG. Bluntly, I read that the game had to change or it would be dropped. This is after I thought it was done. I communicated futher and headed to changing it. Then after a week, communications stopped. It was then when Alan Emrich contacted me and I saw his beast of a game. Wow! It had everything I wanted in the game, and tons more!


From gallery of ropearoni4

VPG prototype


Alan and I talked about the changes, streamlined a bit, then he sent it to a developer. Yep, there was Nathan, back on board for the final voyage of the U.S. H.H.H. Now, we had the priviledge of taming Alan's beast. Streamlining it down, as well as adding to it, became a weekly chore for the next five months. Nathan had some great ideas. I was able to shoot those down as he shot my down as well. Eventually, it was ready — a year from the last scheduled out-of-house playtesting — to get out-of-house testing. Two months of out-of-house testing and it was ready to be sent to the art department...again...to be published. Yay!

Healthy Heart Hospital has been through a lot of development. This is not the game I dropped off at their doorstep three-and-a-half years ago; it is much better. Developers were at every point of this trip. They don't get much credit for what they do, but without their input and willingness to listen to my input, the game would not be what it is. Nathan jumped in and out of this picture many times, but each time he was great to work with. In fact, the whole staff at VPG was great to work with. I am very glad I found the "magic door"...

From gallery of ropearoni4

Final board, with some bits and doctor cards

Related

New Game Round-up: Three from AEG — Goblins Get Greedy, Birds Get Flighty & Animals Get Eaten

New Game Round-up: Three from AEG — Goblins Get Greedy, Birds Get Flighty & Animals Get Eaten

Nov 13, 2015

• Alderac Entertainment Group has released details of three forthcoming titles, with one of them being Richard Garfield's second goblin-related title in a row, the first being Treasure Hunter...

Crowdfunding Round-up: Attacking Two-Player Abstracts, Rolling A Characteristic Victory, and Delivering Us Cave Evil

Crowdfunding Round-up: Attacking Two-Player Abstracts, Rolling A Characteristic Victory, and Delivering Us Cave Evil

Nov 12, 2015

I normally post crowdfunding round-ups on Sundays, but I'm hitting the road soon for another trip and since in the past I've seen c.f. campaigns cancelled between the time I scheduled a post and...

New Game Round-up: More Mythic Battles and More Marvel Games from Upper Deck and WizKids

New Game Round-up: More Mythic Battles and More Marvel Games from Upper Deck and WizKids

Nov 11, 2015

• Wow, I've missed a lot during my post-Spiel recovery period, such as the announcement of a reboot of Benoit Vogt's Mythic Battles, a two-player combat game between armies in mythic Greece...

New Game Round-up: Pyramids Rebuilt, Zombies Return & Cold War Covertly Revisited

New Game Round-up: Pyramids Rebuilt, Zombies Return & Cold War Covertly Revisited

Nov 10, 2015

• Looney Labs will release Pyramid Arcade, a new "Looney Pyramids" compilation of games, in 2016. This collection of 22 games, most of them from Pyramids creator Andy Looney, will include...

Spiel 2015: Reiner Knizia on Thirty Years of Game Design

Spiel 2015: Reiner Knizia on Thirty Years of Game Design

Nov 09, 2015

BGG recorded more than two hundred game demonstration videos at Spiel 2015, and while I'm glad that we were able to cover so many different titles in so little time — with dozens of videos...

ads