Designer Diary: Lotus, or Everything Blooms in Time

Designer Diary: Lotus, or Everything Blooms in Time
Board Game: Lotus
Hi there! We are Jordan and Mandy Goddard. Yep, you guessed it — we are married, and we design games together. We love getting the chance to work on projects together in our free time, and what better hobby than one in which we get to play games all the time! Here is the story on how our latest game, Lotus, came about and how it evolved over the course of two years…

External image


Lotus is a game that was developed mechanisms-first, then grew into its beautiful theme along the way. The process started during the summer of 2014. Our early objective was to create a board game-like experience using cards and no board. We started playing around with how cards are held in your hand and how that same fanned-out shape could be placed down on the table to create a full circle of cards. This led to the development of the game's core mechanism of set completion with five different sets, ranging from three cards to seven cards. Using a little geometry to identify the exact angle of overlap for each set, we were able to guide placement of each card for a clean shape every time.

External image


It didn't take long before the card-laying mechanism naturally led us to a theme of building flowers. That theme, in addition to our desire for a board game experience, led to the addition of butterfly meeples to be used for area control of the flowers in the garden. We gave the design the name "Bloom" and got to work on a ruleset and petal card illustrations.

It doesn't always make sense to invest in full art so early in the game design process, but in this case, the petal cards actually help enable the mechanism by providing guides for placing the next card in the set. The art also provides a visual indicator of progress toward the completion of each flower, which is helpful during gameplay. We had a full art prototype made to confirm whether our vision was going to work as we expected. It was time to move on to playtesting!

External image


Thanks to the great community at Unpub and the Blue Noodle, we were able to show our design to a large number of wonderful people and receive incredibly valuable feedback. Their countless hours of playtesting various iterations and providing detailed suggestions helped us polish the details. We also leaned on the Reddit community, specifically the TabletopGameDesign subreddit, for some early feedback on artwork and general concepts of the game. You could even say this process led to some budding friendships.

External image

Daryl Andrews, Gil Hova, Jordan Goddard, Ian Zang, Tony Miller, Mandy Goddard, Isaac Shalev (back row)
Tiffany Caires, Daniel Newman (front row)


About a year into our project, in the summer of 2015, we partnered with Renegade Game Studios. It was a wonderful experience working with the Renegade team and collaborating with their extended network of game designers and artists. While the core mechanisms of the game remained unchanged, there were a few significant improvements made as a result of working with the new team.

Theme and Visual Aesthetics

We learned that the name "Bloom" was already taken by a European game, so we started brainstorming alternatives. (Two examples were "Blossom" and "Garden in Bloom".) The final decision for "Lotus" didn't come about until after we landed on the idea for the box art. Kane Klenko (designer of Covert, FUSE, and Dead Men Tell No Tales) led the art direction for Lotus and we owe him a HUGE thank you for how beautifully everything came together. Illustrations were provided by Chris Ostrowski and graphic design by Anita Osburn — what an amazing team!

Board Game: Lotus
The box cover took on a clean, inviting, mysterious feeling through the use of negative white space to draw attention to the gorgeous Asian-inspired artwork. The petal cards bring the game to life with their bright, bold colors and natural imperfections that allow for no two completed flowers to look exactly the same.

The final theme was a result of the art direction — or at least of a feeling the art evoked. Players are invited into a mysterious lotus garden where they compete for flowers in order to harness the wisdom that the mystical blossoms provide. Each player also commands a set of insect guardians that helps them gain control of flowers and aids them in gaining special abilities to make their quest more successful.

External image


Mechanism and Components

For what may seem like a fairly simple set of rules, the game did pose a number of challenges for us during playtesting. It's interesting to look back now to remember how much it really changed over the course of two years in development.

Below are a few examples of ideas we tested that didn't make it into the final version of the game. We also show the issues that kept these ideas from working and the solution that was implemented in the final version of Lotus.

External image


A few more tweaks here and terminology updates there, and we finally had the Lotus rules. Final components were also taking shape, including a change from using just butterfly meeples to including three other critters — ladybugs, dragonflies, and caterpillars — to round out the mix of insect guardians.

External image


The most fulfilling part of the entire process was supporting the launch of Lotus at Renegade's booth at Gen Con 2016. The reception of the game was so positive, and we are just so excited to see other people enjoying playing with their families and friends. If you have a chance to play, we would love to hear your feedback on Twitter @JordanandMandy.

External image


Thank you so much to everyone who helped us along the way!

Jordan and Mandy Goddard

Related

WizKids and Lookout Games to Partner on Agricola Mini-Expansions

WizKids and Lookout Games to Partner on Agricola Mini-Expansions

Oct 25, 2016

WizKids has announced a licensing partnership with Lookout Games for the publication of six Agricola Upgrade Kits in 2017, with each of these mini-expansions containing "five highly detailed...

F2Z Entertainment Is Now Asmodée Canada

F2Z Entertainment Is Now Asmodée Canada

Oct 24, 2016

In July 2016, the Asmodee Group — which is owned by French investment company Eurazeo — announced that it had entered into exclusive discussions to acquire F2Z Entertainment Inc., the...

Yarrington Responds to Shlasinger's Lawsuit over Fraud and Breach of Contract

Yarrington Responds to Shlasinger's Lawsuit over Fraud and Breach of Contract

Oct 24, 2016

In June 2016, Zev Shlasinger and Paul Gerardi filed suit against Dan Yarrington and Myriad Games, Yarrington's game retail operation in New Hampshire, alleging that Yarrington committed "Fraud...

Links: SPIEL 2016 Attendance, AEG Channels, & Brick-and-Mortar Pyramids

Links: SPIEL 2016 Attendance, AEG Channels, & Brick-and-Mortar Pyramids

Oct 23, 2016

• Time to catch up on industry news both recent and aged, some of which has been sitting in the inbox for months waiting for me to put aside SPIEL-related info — which makes it somewhat...

New Game Round-up: Feeding Dingos, Hunting Spies, Detecting Batman, & Mastering Orion

New Game Round-up: Feeding Dingos, Hunting Spies, Detecting Batman, & Mastering Orion

Oct 22, 2016

More news and announcements that slipped through the cracks while I focused on SPIEL 2016:• Upper Deck Entertainment plans to release Mike Elliott's The Dingo Ate The Baby in March 2017, with...

ads