Game Preview: Reef, or Cracking the Four-Color Coral Theorem

Game Preview: Reef, or Cracking the Four-Color Coral Theorem
Board Game: Reef
With all the hundreds of game announcements that I've seen so far in 2018, I feel like Emerson Matsuuchi's Reef from Next Move Games is old news. After all, I covered the announcement of the game in early January 2018, we recorded an overview video in Cannes in late February 2018, and we had Emerson himself present the game on camera at Origins in June 2018. Aren't we done with this game?

Oh, wait, it's not even out yet?! True, true — Reef has a U.S. retail release date of September 27, 2018, so while a few hundred people have picked up the game at Origins or Gen Con, most of this game's potential players have never seen a copy and quite possibly have never even heard about it. Many of us on BGG are plugged in to all that's hitting the market or being shown at conventions, but that's not how most people experience games, so let's give Reef a once over for all those just diving into the ocean.


From gallery of W Eric Martin


Reef challenges you to build your own collection of coral, and while you are free to place the four colors of coral in whatever arrangement you like, you won't score any points unless you create patterns that match what's shown on the cards in your hand.

Each player starts with two cards, and each card shows two pieces of coral that you must place in your personal reef when you play the card and a scoring pattern that (almost always) is for colors other than what you just placed. On a turn, you either draft a new card from the display or play a card from your hand, then build and (possibly) score.

Points are sparse in the early turns because you'll typically have a particular arrangement on your board only one or two times. As the game progresses, though, you'll often draft a card or two that will score big as long you can find the right other cards to play ahead of it. Will you score those other cards as well? I hope so or else you might be wasting your time. Playing Reef is like riding a bicycle down a hill while simultaneously inflating the wheels. Every card is play is adding bits to your reef, but if you're not scoring points in the process, then you'll be dragging behind other players and one huge score near game's end won't help you catch others who have been keeping the momentum flowing constantly.


From gallery of W Eric Martin
Ready to combo out cards from right to left while draining purple along the way


No one can mess with the bicycle you've built, but they can definitely snatch the pump from your hands. Watching the color flow on the cards drafted gives you an idea of what players will do on future turns, and sometimes it's worth your time to grab a middling card for you that someone else will transform into a rocket. If nothing else, you can still score the cards left in your hand when the game ends — which occurs when one color of coral has been exhausted — so if you would have scored that card only once anyway, now you'll still score it without having to expend a turn to do so.

The trick about this endgame scoring, however, is that if you would have scored something multiple times, you still score it only once, so you can't sit on things forever — which you wouldn't do anyway since you have a limit of four cards in hand. If you think the game is going to end, you need to get those cards out there to do the multi-scores, but then you'll be taking more coral from the pool and possibly hastening the end of the game in the process!

I've played Reef eight times now with all player counts (2-4) on both a pre-production copy and a review copy from Next Move, and the two-player game has been my favorite because you have more control over what the opponent can do via hate drafting, in addition to having a better handle on which colors are plentiful and which will likely score you nothing. In the image above, for example, you can see that I have exactly one green piece of coral — the one I started the game with — and all four cards are providing yellow coral while scoring other things. I feel you get weird situations like that more frequently in two-player games because fewer cards are taken overall, so you need to catch on to when such things are happening as early as possible in order to make the most of what you draft and what you let drift away...


Related

Pretzel Games Invites You to Play with Men At Work

Pretzel Games Invites You to Play with Men At Work

Sep 20, 2018

Canadian publisher Pretzel Games has a low-key release strategy: Once a year, publish a huge dexterity game with dozens of wooden bits.This release pattern started in 2015 with Flick 'em Up, and...

Game Preview: Monster Crunch!, or Nostalgia Served Up Right

Game Preview: Monster Crunch!, or Nostalgia Served Up Right

Sep 19, 2018

In general I like my approach to making game overview videos. I play the game several times, ideally with different players and with different player counts, then I think about the game to some...

New Game Round-up: Count Crops in Catan, Connect Animals in Eco-Links, and Do...Something in Scientia

New Game Round-up: Count Crops in Catan, Connect Animals in Eco-Links, and Do...Something in Scientia

Sep 18, 2018

• Catan is the Little Engine That Could in the hobby game world. I rarely hear long-time gamers talk about playing Catan at game night, yet it keeps chugging along in the background, with...

Hans im Glück Prepares to Lift Off at SPIEL '18, While Mississippi Queen Fires Up the Coal Again

Hans im Glück Prepares to Lift Off at SPIEL '18, While Mississippi Queen Fires Up the Coal Again

Sep 17, 2018

• I've already covered two SPIEL '18 releases coming from Hans im Glück — Carcassonne: Safari and Stone Age: Jubiläumsedition — but aside from that spinoff title and the anniversary...

SPIEL '18 Preview: Discovery: The Era of Voyage, or Sailing in Circles

SPIEL '18 Preview: Discovery: The Era of Voyage, or Sailing in Circles

Sep 17, 2018

For as much as I feel that I have some idea of what is going on in the Japanese game market, I'm frequently reminded that I know next to nothing, or perhaps more charitably, more than most people...

ads