Fantasy Flight and Stronghold Resolve Their Merchant of Venus Imbroglio

Fantasy Flight and Stronghold Resolve Their Merchant of Venus Imbroglio
Board Game: Merchant of Venus (Second Edition)
• On October 20, 2011, at the annual Spiel game convention in Essen, Germany, U.S. publisher Stronghold Games announced that it had signed a deal with designer Richard Hamblen for a new edition of his Merchant of Venus. The following day, U.S. publisher Fantasy Flight Games announced its own new edition of Merchant of Venus, noting that it had "signed an exclusive licensing contract with Wizards of the Coast, LLC, a subsidiary of Hasbro, Inc." – with Hasbro having purchased Merchant's original publisher Avalon Hill. (Additional background from the competing dual announcements in a Nov. 1, 2011 BGGN post.)

Now the Merchant of Venus situation has been resolved, according to both parties involved, with the Fantasy Flight version of the game proceeding and the Stronghold Games one cancelled – but not really, as the "classic" Stronghold version will now be included with the re-imagined FFG design from Rob Kouba. (The game board will be double-sided with the new version on one side and the "classic" version on the other. A breakdown of the components and what's different in the Kouba version has not been revealed.)

More on the resolution from a press release from Stronghold Games:

Quote:
Today, FFG and SG jointly announce that FFG will proceed to publish its new edition of Merchant of Venus, while SG's version of the game will be cancelled. SG will act as a consultant on FFG's version of the game, bringing some of SG's creative vision to the final release.

"This was a difficult and confusing situation," said Christian T. Petersen, CEO of Fantasy Flight Games. "All parties involved clearly had the best intentions in mind for the game, and none sought to cause damage to the other company. After a period of discussion and discovery, I'm thrilled that all parties now have clarity on the situation. I want to express my gratitude to WOTC for their assistance in this matter, and especially to Stephen Buonocore, the President of Stronghold Games, who has been both professional and practical in untangling this issue."

"While this was an unfortunate situation for all parties, everyone is a winner in the end," said Stephen M. Buonocore, President of Stronghold Games. "Fantasy Flight Games and Stronghold Games have forged a great bond that will last long after this event. In the face of crisis, Christian Petersen was a true leader who worked tirelessly to resolve the matter, and I am very thankful to him for that. The WOTC team was also instrumental in getting this done smoothly, and they too should be lauded. And above all, gamers worldwide are the biggest winners, since they will have this great game back in print, published by a great company, Fantasy Flight Games."

FFG is planning to release its new version of Merchant of Venus in Fall 2012. The new edition will feature both the classic game design by Richard Hamblen, as well as an updated game inspired by the original, designed by FFG's Rob Kouba. Stronghold Games is in discussion with Richard Hamblen with regard to other game designs, both old and new ones, which they hope to publish in 2013.
(As noted in an April 2012 BGGN post, Stronghold Games filed for trademark registration of the name "Magic Realm" in October 2011. No announcement for a new edition of Hamblen's Magic Realm has been made, however.)

Both Petersen and Buonocore appeared in episode #262 of The Dice Tower to talk about the resolution of the conflict and how the now two-for-one Merchant of Venus game will debut at Spiel 2012.

Related

New Game Round-up: Catching Streams of Numbers, Moving Trucks of Goods & Eyeing Games from CGE

New Game Round-up: Catching Streams of Numbers, Moving Trucks of Goods & Eyeing Games from CGE

Jun 26, 2012

• French publisher Moonster Games will release a new version of Yoshihisa Itsubaki's Streams in September 2012, with rules in English, French and Korean, and Asmodee handling distribution in...

Designer Diary: Tooth & Nail: Factions – Battle Beasts, Boston Terriers and World War Zoo

Designer Diary: Tooth & Nail: Factions – Battle Beasts, Boston Terriers and World War Zoo

Jun 26, 2012

If you were born in the 1980s, like I was, then you may be familiar with my favorite toy from childhood: Battle Beasts. God, I loved those things. I can remember my folks taking me to Kay-Bee Toy...

Links: Faidutti Starts Blogging, Rosewater Explains Game Explanations & MIT Reinvents Sand

Links: Faidutti Starts Blogging, Rosewater Explains Game Explanations & MIT Reinvents Sand

Jun 26, 2012

• Designer Bruno Faidutti, who announced in May 2012 that he planned to shutter his website and launch a new blog, has indeed launched that blog, but his Ideal Game Library and the rest of his...

Gen Con 2012 Preview Now Live on BGG

Gen Con 2012 Preview Now Live on BGG

Jun 25, 2012

Gen Con Indy 2012 takes place August 16-19, 2012, and as the largest and longest-running game convention in the U.S. – more than forty years! – it's no surprise that U.S. publishers will demo...

Designer Diary: Smash Up – The Winding Road from Idea to Published Game

Designer Diary: Smash Up – The Winding Road from Idea to Published Game

Jun 25, 2012

It started with an idea. It wasn't even an idea for a theme or a game – just a mechanism for setting up a game. I wanted to capture the excitement of building decks in collectible card games,...

ads